Posted in

How to test the strength of a rivet?

Hey there, Rivet

So, if you’re here, you’re probably either a fellow fabrication shop owner, a maintenance tech trying to figure out why that last batch of rivets failed on your bridge bracket, or maybe even someone who’s just curious how we make sure those little metal pins holding everything together actually work. Full transparency – I’m the head of quality control here at our rivet supply shop, and over the past 12 years, I’ve tested more rivets than I can count. Some days, I swear I can tell a dud from a good one just by holding it (don’t tell my team I said that – they’ll make me prove it every time), but that’s just a party trick. The real way to test rivet strength? It’s science, but not the stuff that makes you cry during chemistry exams. Let’s break it down like we’re chatting over coffee after a long day of installs.

First off, let’s get one thing straight: not all rivets are made the same, and they’re not all tested the same way either. A rivet holding a tiny jewelry clasp? It doesn’t need the same strength as one holding a steel beam on a skyscraper. Our shop supplies everything from small pop rivets for HVAC ductwork to heavy-duty structural rivets for bridges, so we tailor our tests to what the rivet’s actually going to do. That’s the mistake a lot of new guys make – they use a one-test-fits-all approach, and end up with either rivets that’re way too flimsy or way too expensive for the job.

Let’s start with the most common test we do here, and probably the one you’ve heard of if you’ve ever worked with metal: the tensile shear test. Wait, before you zone out – tensile shear just means we’re pulling the rivet in two different directions until it breaks, right? No fancy jargon, I promise. Here’s how we do it step by step, no lab coat required (though we do wear safety glasses – hard hats too, if we’re testing heavy rivets). First, we take 10 randomly selected rivets from every batch that leaves our shop. Why 10? Because if 9 out of 10 are solid, that’s a good batch – if more than 1’s off, we flag it for a redo. We cut each rivet to a standard length (usually whatever’s used for the most common application, so we get real-world results) and mount it between two steel plates. The plates have a hole the exact size of the rivet, so when we pull them, the rivet’s got to hold both plates together without slipping or breaking.

We use a hydraulic press for this – it’s just a big machine that applies slow, steady pressure (we never yank fast, that messes with results) until the rivet snaps or pulls out of the plates. For small pop rivets, that pressure might be 500 pounds; for structural ones? We’re talking 50,000 pounds or more. Last month, we tested a batch of 3/4-inch steel rivets for a highway overpass project – one of them broke at 62,000 pounds, which was just under our 65,000-pound threshold. We sent that whole batch back, no questions asked. Our client was frustrated at first, but when we showed them the test data and gave them a new batch that hit 68,000 pounds, they thanked us later. Turns out, cutting corners on testing costs way more than waiting an extra day for good rivets.

But tensile shear isn’t the only test we run. Sometimes, we do a block shear test, which is basically the same idea but we’re testing the rivet’s ability to hold two chunks of metal that get sheared apart, not just two flat plates. This is super important for rivets used in heavy machinery or trailer frames – those places get yanked and twisted all the time, not just pulled straight. Last year, we had a client who was using our rivets for their semi-trailer cross members. Their initial tests were all great on tensile shear, but when we did block shear, a couple rivets started bending at 40,000 pounds. Turns out, their cross members were getting pulled at an angle, not straight, so our standard tensile test didn’t catch the weakness. We adjusted their order to a higher-grade alloy rivet, and they haven’t had a rivet failure since. That’s the stuff that keeps us in business – fixing problems before the client even knows they have them.

Now, here’s a test that a lot of small shops skip, but it’s super important for making sure rivets don’t just break, but hold their shape when they’re installed: the hardness test. Wait, hardness isn’t the same as strength, right? Yeah, that’s a common mix-up. A rivet can be hard but brittle, which means it’ll snap under pressure instead of bending a little to take the load. That’s a disaster in places where there’s vibration – like on wind turbine blades or train tracks. We use a portable hardness tester here – it’s like a tiny gun that presses a diamond tip into the rivet’s head and measures how much it dents. For most structural rivets, we want a hardness of 25-35 HRC (that’s hardness rating, for anyone who cares). If it’s below 25, it’s too soft and might bend when you set it; above 35, it’s too hard and could crack if there’s any movement. Last quarter, we had a batch of stainless steel rivets that came in at 38 HRC. Our team flagged ’em immediately – those would’ve snapped on a construction site within a month. The supplier thought hardness was just a number, but we know it’s what makes the rivet reliable in the real world.

We also do a impact test sometimes, though not for every batch. That’s where we take a finished rivet and whack it with a big hammer (or an impact testing machine, if we’re being fancy) and see if it cracks. For rivets that get set by hand – like in aircraft repairs or custom metalwork – this is key. If you hit a rivet too hard when setting it, it shouldn’t shatter. A few years back, a custom aircraft builder ordered a batch of 1/8-inch aluminum rivets. Their initial tests passed tensile, but when we did the impact test, 2 out of 15 cracked when we tapped them with a rivet gun. Turns out, the alloy they used was too thin, so it couldn’t handle the force of being set. We swapped them for a slightly thicker grade, and they’ve been a repeat client ever since.

Wait, let’s talk about the testing we do on-site, not just in our shop. Because a rivet that passes our lab tests is great, but we need to make sure it works when someone’s actually installing it. For example, when we ship heavy structural rivets, we include a set of instructions for setting them with a hydraulic rivet gun – not a pneumatic one, because too much air pressure can mess up the rivet’s strength. We also offer on-site testing for our big clients – like when we supplied rivets for a new stadium downtown, we sent a team to help them test a sample section before the main install. They set 10 test rivets and pulled on the beam with a winch, and none of them budged an inch. That gave everyone peace of mind, and the project’s been going smoothly for two years now.

Here’s something a lot of people don’t know: we also test for corrosion resistance, even though that’s not exactly “strength” – but a rivet that rusts through in 6 months is useless, right? We do a salt spray test, where we spray the rivet with a salt water solution for 1000 hours and check for rust. For our marine-grade rivets, that’s non-negotiable. Last year, a boat builder came to us complaining that their old rivets were rusting out after one season. We tested their old rivets – their salt spray test only lasted 200 hours before rust spots showed up – and sent them our marine-grade aluminum rivets, which hit 1200 hours with no rust. They’ve now switched all their suppliers to us for every new boat they build.

Now, let’s get real about what “strength” actually means here. It’s not just about how much weight a rivet can hold in a lab. It’s about how it performs over time. A rivet that passes all our tests might still fail if it’s used for the wrong job. For example, don’t use a small pop rivet meant for a mail box on a bridge. That’s why we always ask our clients about their specific application when they order – it’s not one-size-fits-all. We’ve had guys try to save a buck by ordering the cheapest rivets for a heavy-duty job, and they come back to us a month later with a mess of broken rivets and a lot of explaining to do. Our advice is always: tell us what you’re doing, we’ll tell you exactly what rivet you need, and we’ll test it to make sure it works.

I should also mention that we don’t just test our own rivets – we’ll test rivets from other suppliers for clients too. A lot of times, shops get stuck with a batch of rivets that they’re not sure about, and they bring ’em to us to run the tests. Last month, a small fabrication shop in town brought us a box of rivets they’d ordered online from a “discount supplier” – they were supposed to be structural grade, but our tests showed they were 20% weaker than they claimed. We ended up selling them the correct grade from us for less than it would’ve cost them to rework their entire project, and they’re now a regular customer. That’s the thing about our shop – we’re not just here to sell rivets, we’re here to make sure our clients’ jobs don’t fall apart (literally).

So, what’s the takeaway here? Testing rivet strength isn’t just pulling on it until it breaks. It’s a combination of tensile shear, block shear, hardness, impact, and even corrosion testing, all tailored to what the rivet’s actually going to be used for. It’s not complicated, but it needs to be done right, with real data, not just guesswork. At our shop, that’s what we do every single day. We don’t cut corners, we don’t sell rivets that haven’t been tested, and we’ll always help you figure out exactly what you need, whether you’re a small hobbyist or a big construction company.

If you’re in the market for reliable, tested rivets, or you’ve got a batch you’re not sure about and want us to run some tests, hit us up. We’re here to answer questions, send over test data for any batch, and make sure whatever project you’re working on is solid. No fancy sales talk, just good rivets and real results. Let’s connect and get your job done right.

High Voltage DC Contactor AJH Series References:

  1. American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) B18.1.1 – Steel Rivets for General Applications
  2. ASTM E8/E8M – Standard Test Methods for Tension Testing of Metallic Materials
  3. ASTM A370 – Standard Test Methods and Definitions for Mechanical Testing of Steel Products
  4. Metal Supermarkets – Guide to Rivet Testing and Selection for Structural Applications

Zhejiang Aokai Electric Co., Ltd.
Zhejiang Aokai Electric Co., Ltd. is your best source for the high quality rivet with CE certification. We have been one of the largest rivet manufacturers and suppliers in China since our establishment in 2008. Welcome to contact our factory for the products.
Address: No.166 Xiangbai Road, Huxi Industrial, Yueqing, China.
E-mail: akcontactor@aokai.com
WebSite: https://www.ak-contactor.com/